An American in Lyon: Old and New Memories of France
I know, I know: in a blog about Amsterdam, I manage to get you out of the city quite a bit. Believe it or not, compared to some of our rolling stone expat friends, we travel relatively little. A few weeks ago, Peter and I spent a weekend in Lyon. What's in Lyon? you ask. I certainly did when Peter first asked me if I wanted to go. As those of you who know Peter well know, he has been a "foodie" since before it became a term. Actually, the term "foodie" - which makes me think about a person who drops names about wines and Michelin-star restaurants - doesn't really describe his relationship to food. He just likes to cook and is really good at it. A favorite Saturday or Sunday for him is spent watching cooking shows on T.V., then scouring his many cookbooks for recipes inspired by all that viewing. Next there's the trip to the grocery store for ingredients, the preparation, and then finally the eating. He doesn't go in for those fussy meals with stacked-up food, foams, and garnishes. It's all just really plentiful, and delicious. So for Peter, going to Lyon, France's third largest city, the "food capital of the world", was like an avid scuba diver visiting the Great Barrier Reef, or a book lover going to Powell's Books in Portland, Oregon. It was a chance to go to the epicenter of food and find out if it had truly earned all the heaped upon praise.
And who was I, the most frequent guest at Peter's restaurant, to pass up the chance to eat myself silly in the Mecca of good food? Those who know me well know that I am a very appreciative audience when it comes to food. This has always been a part of who I am. Here's a little known piece of Vine-Drucker foodlore: soon after I met Peter in law school, he invited me to come over for Chinese food. I assumed that meant we would order in, or if he was really fancy/wanted to impress me, he might stir-fry some random vegetables together. Imagine my surprise when he presented me with homemade soup (in my memory bank, he served it in a tureen, but I don't know if that's really true or a dream), chicken with walnuts, and a whole fish. You might have some serious doubts about a person who remembers in such detail a meal she ate 30 years ago. The ability to recall those details with such clarity might have something to do with how many times I have told that Chinese food story. On the other hand, you might be impressed by this person's sharp memory. I can assure you that she can remember long-ago food experiences like they were yesterday, but has trouble recalling the plot of a book she finished last week. There are books written about this subject. I think I have even written in this blog about this ability of mine to conjure up my food-connected memories. I can't really remember. More on this later in in the blog post when we get to a discussion of Proust. Excited?
Back to the present day and the Lyon trip: A first-thing-in-the-morning flight meant we hit the ground running in Lyon by 10 a.m. We made our way to the outdoor markets along the Saône River, where regular folk like us shop alongside famous chefs. I imagined that the leeks splayed on the wooden table with abandon might grace my dinner plate that night. We immediately bought some slabs of quiche and ate them American-style - as in right away as we walked along the market stalls. There's a special place in my heart for the bread we ate in Lyon. Sorry to say, Amsterdam, but your bread just can't hold a candle to Lyon's version: just the right ratio of crunchy exterior to soft but not cottony interior. It was just right on the money in each and every restaurant we visited. The food in France is just, well, sexier, than what we are used to in Amsterdam. I found myself thinking back to one of my old time faves, Justin Timberlake's Sexyback. In this cover by Corrine Bailey Rae, the sexiness is a little more subtle. Feel free to also take a listen to the original as you think about French food.
Where did this love of all things French - except maybe their lack of interest in daily showering - begin? For me, I have to go all the way back to 5th grade to trace my fascination. As I mentioned in my post about trying to learn Dutch, I loved learning French. That may have something to do with the fact that Madame Echevarria slipped us candies throughout the lessons. I think it was also because I just liked the sound of it. The French could be arguing about a parking spot and manage to make it sound interesting, intelligent, and most of all, beautful. In addition to my early success with learning French, the film The Red Balloon had a huge influence on me, no doubt. Every single person around my tender age must remember watching that film on "public TV", don't you? Each time I watched it, I wanted the little boy to escape those bullies and save his precious red balloon. Each time I hoped, just this once, he would. Watching him walk through the streets of Paris must have planted the seeds for my love of wandering the streets of French cities.
The third road leading to my France-love began when I spent the summer I turned sixteen in Brittany, in a little town called Perros Guirec. I went on a summer study program with a bunch of other American teenagers. We had French lessons in the morning, then spent the afternoons learning to cook, sail, and play tennis, all in French. No wonder I'm not very good at any of those things. Mostly, I remember the food: the baguettes we tore open and ate with squares of chocolate, the Breton crêpes, the butter cookies we called "Mad Holes" (help me out, French friends. Trou Fou?). This all took place way before the days of iPhone photos and Facebook posts. Thank god for my box of old photos, which I have somehow managed not to lose. I must have had a premonition that one day, I would need to show this photo to others, to prove how beautiful Brittany is and that I was actually there. And thank god for the Internet. It helped me find a recipe that looks like a close friend of Mad Holes.
You can't mention a cookie in a post about France without mentioning the most famous cookie ever to appear in literature: the madeleine in Proust's Remembrance of Things Past. For those of you who care, here is one passage from the book about that cookie and its effect on the character's memory:
She sent for one of those squat, plump little cakes called "petites madeleines," which look as though they had been moulded in the fluted valve of a scallop shell. And soon, mechanically, dispirited after a dreary day with the prospect of a depressing morrow, I raised to my lips a spoonful of the tea in which I had soaked a morsel of the cake. No sooner had the warm liquid mixed with the crumbs touched my palate than a shudder ran through me and I stopped, intent upon the extraordinary thing that was happening to me. An exquisite pleasure had invaded my senses, something isolated, detached, with no suggestion of its origin. And at once the vicissitudes of life had become indifferent to me, its disasters innocuous, its brevity illusory - this new sensation having had on me the effect which love has of filling me with a precious essence; or rather this essence was not in me it was me. I had ceased now to feel mediocre, contingent, mortal. Whence could it have come to me, this all-powerful joy? I sensed that it was connected with the taste of the tea and the cake, but that it infinitely transcended those savours, could, no, indeed, be of the same nature. Whence did it come? What did it mean? How could I seize and apprehend it?
If I go back to Brittany (and that's on the to-do list while we are in Amsterdam) I plan on finding those Breton butter cookies and having the taste instantly transport me back to my 16 year-old-self. I'll keep you posted.
I could go on and on: telling you about how I loved to watch Julia Child on The French Chef on Saturday afternoons with my mom, and how I adored Maurice Chevalier. I had the easy-play songbook for Gigi. Somehow, my rendition on the piano never sounded as smooth as his voice. And then there was his accent.... And that smile....
That was a very long trip down memory lane. Let's get back to Lyon. After our visit to the outdoor food market, we visited the indoor market/temple of fine food: Les Halles de Lyon Paul Bocuse. For those of you who don't follow food news, Monsieur Bocuse is the Ted Williams of the food world. (Since it's World Series time, I went with a baseball reference. Those of you who follow baseball even less than food will just have to miss the analogy). He's a classic. He's been at it forever, and he shuns the fussy stuff in favor of traditions.
The neighborhood was brimming with food-related shops. Peter loves kitchen stores, and this one didn't disappoint. I'll tell you what was disappointing: his refusal to try on the chef's chapeau so I could snap his photo for the blog.
To ready ourselves for our first Lyon dinner, we climbed up and up the hill to see some Roman ruins: the ancient theater of Fourvière. The theater was built starting in 15 B.C. We felt silly complaining about the steep walk up the hill when we thought about the Romans trudging from Italy to France with huge slabs of rock to build this thing.
After our long walk over the twin rivers, the Saône and the Rhône - I'm loving the chance to add that circumflex over the o's in two words in one sentence - we were ready for anything our restaurant chef was ready to throw our way. The sense of anticipation was almost visible in the air outside Daniel and Denise. It's one of the most beloved Lyonnais bouchons, restaurants serving typical food from the region: duck paté, sausages, and other mystery meats. I was determined not to ask too many questions about what came from which part of the animal and just enjoy. We all waited patiently for the doors to open at 7 p.m. for the first seating.
After a long and luxurious meal that included some of those fabled Lyonnais specialties, we walked back to the hotel. The city was all lit up, as if to say, "Take that, Paris. I'm just as glam."
Day Two in Lyon found us taking a break from food tourism to check out the huge flea market in Villeurbanne. It's a bit of a trek on a tram, and then a walk, but you know you're getting close when you see cars jammed up against each other along the side of the road. We wandered up and down the aisles of stalls - reportedly around 400 of them designed for you to find that perfect bargain - along with families with kids and dogs, hipsters, and probably a few tourists like us.
Then, in advance of our second Lyonnais dinner, we walked to and around the gorgeous Park de La Tête d'Or. A Sunday afternoon in the park felt like a very French thing to do. The park was filled with people walking, running, biking, and even one fellow walking on a rope stretched between two trees. I assumed everyone was walking off one meal and getting ready for the next. Isn't that what everyone is doing in Lyon?
All that walking put us in good stead for our dinner at Carré Royal. The server/owner was delighted to hear me speak a little French. So delighted, actually, that she launched into a full dissertation in rapid-fire French on the different white wines on the menu. When we finally stopped her to admit that I didn't quite understand all of her wonderful descriptions, she happily switched to English, calling one of the wines "fat". We later realized she meant "full-bodied". The place was gorgeous, the food was delicious, the price for those four courses really reasonable, and best of all, it was open on a Sunday, which most of the other restaurants were not.
We spent the last day in Lyon at the Musée Des Beaux Arts de Lyon, a grand old museum with a lovely courtyard inside. And we managed to squeeze in one more delicious meal, a late lunch, before boarding our plane back to Amsterdam. We were surrounded by tables of French couples and groups, chatting away over their long, luxurious meals. This was in stark contrast to a typical lunch scene in Amsterdam, which mostly involves sandwiches. The tradition in the Netherlands is that you only have one "warm" meal a day, usually at dinner time. Americans I know who are married to Dutch men verify that their in-laws say that if you have a warm meal at lunch, you need only eat a sandwich at dinnertime. Imagine the French (or Spanish or Italians) foregoing either the long, warm lunch or the longer - and equally warm - dinner. We could chat about whether those warm and unhurried lunch traditions have had an affect on the economic productivity in countries who follow that custom, but that's a subject for another post.
I'm not sure what this next song is actually supposed to be about, but it reminds me of my main job in a house where I'm not the main chef: doing the dishes. I heard this song in a recent spin class, and if you sing it in your head as you wash, it makes the time and the task go by really quickly.
I wasn't sad about returning to Amsterdam. However, I felt a little guilty to tell the truth, as if I had been unfaithful somehow. I had spent the weekend with some sexy French food, and was more than a little wistful about leaving it behind. As you can probably tell from some of the photos, Peter was in heaven. For a man who can spend an entire dinner conversation talking about the relative merits of different styles of Southern barbecue, this was a chance to taste some foods he had read about, but never had the chance to get fully acquainted with over dinner. I was happy to be his companion on this journey to his happy place.
I couldn't help but wonder what life is like for American expats living in France. Do they take for granted their perfect baguettes, the musical language, the grand buildings? Do they look forward to a change of pace and come to Amsterdam for the sandwiches, the coziness, the small-scale beauty? Maybe the grass is always greener on the other side of the plate.
Years ago, I wrote to my great-aunt Sue, my grandmother's sister. She was living in a nursing home in New York City. She wrote back with the following words, which have stayed with me: "[Your letter] brought back pleasant memories. I would give up a million tomorrows for just one yesterday." That struck me as so sad - both at the time I received the letter when I was in my 20's - and now. I'm thinking of my friend Kelly, who died 19 years ago today. She would have given anything for just one tomorrow. I'm not sure what all of this means about the importance of memories. Maybe when you are old, they loom larger because they are the only times of joy you have. But memories are important not just to those at the end of their lives. Our friends and family stay with us, long after they are gone, because of all the memories we so carefully and lovingly save of them. And while those shoe-boxes of memories are important, so are the chances to create new ones, with exciting tomorrows.